Toss the pulse of light up.

[Vilas Tamhane]

On Sep 14, 10:15 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

On Sep 14, 9:43 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

On Sep 14, 8:34 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

When I toss a ball up it is bounced back in my hand with certain
velocity. If I do that in a train compartment, always tossing
with equal force, whatever might be the velocity of the train,
there is never a change in velocity of the ball. Why?
I now toss up a pulse of light on the mirror and I always receive
the pulse with unchanged velocity c at the source. Why?

It appears to me that all are averse to discuss the question I
raised for fear of shaking fundamental aspect of SR. So I would
like to make my argument.

That is the problem. You show *no understanding whatsoever*
of physics 101 (which means level age-13) and you are here to
make arguments about a topic of advanced physics.
You don't have the background, you don't have the maturity, and
you don't have the mind-set for having such discussions. Go to
school, do some real hard work, and come back in 10 years of so.
Dirk Vdm

You mean to say I should learn by rote, school physics as well as
advanced physics, the way you did?

You are here with the argument that airplanes cannot possibly fly
because they are heavier than air. Imbecile.
Dirk Vdm

This is just to remind you. You said, you don’t love physics. You just
find it interesting. Your anger says something else. I think you are
in love of physics, especially SR.

Ping alen...
My apologies, you were correct, there is no hope for Tamhane
either :-)
Dirk Vdm- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -

Thanks for the compliments.

[Vilas Tamhane]

On Sep 14, 10:15 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

On Sep 14, 9:43 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

On Sep 14, 8:34 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

When I toss a ball up it is bounced back in my hand with certain
velocity. If I do that in a train compartment, always tossing
with equal force, whatever might be the velocity of the train,
there is never a change in velocity of the ball. Why?
I now toss up a pulse of light on the mirror and I always receive
the pulse with unchanged velocity c at the source. Why?

It appears to me that all are averse to discuss the question I
raised for fear of shaking fundamental aspect of SR. So I would
like to make my argument.

That is the problem. You show *no understanding whatsoever*
of physics 101 (which means level age-13) and you are here to
make arguments about a topic of advanced physics.
You don't have the background, you don't have the maturity, and
you don't have the mind-set for having such discussions. Go to
school, do some real hard work, and come back in 10 years of so.
Dirk Vdm

You mean to say I should learn by rote, school physics as well as
advanced physics, the way you did?

You are here with the argument that airplanes cannot possibly fly
because they are heavier than air. Imbecile.
Dirk Vdm

This is just to remind you. You said, you don’t love physics. You just
find it interesting. Your anger says something else. I think you are
in love of physics, especially SR.

Ping alen...
My apologies, you were correct, there is no hope for Tamhane
either :-)
Dirk Vdm- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -

I posted a message,
"Thanks for the compliments."
Why the message disappeared?

[Vilas Tamhane]

On Sep 14, 10:15 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

On Sep 14, 9:43 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

On Sep 14, 8:34 am, "Dirk Van de moortel"

When I toss a ball up it is bounced back in my hand with certain
velocity. If I do that in a train compartment, always tossing
with equal force, whatever might be the velocity of the train,
there is never a change in velocity of the ball. Why?
I now toss up a pulse of light on the mirror and I always receive
the pulse with unchanged velocity c at the source. Why?

It appears to me that all are averse to discuss the question I
raised for fear of shaking fundamental aspect of SR. So I would
like to make my argument.

That is the problem. You show *no understanding whatsoever*
of physics 101 (which means level age-13) and you are here to
make arguments about a topic of advanced physics.
You don't have the background, you don't have the maturity, and
you don't have the mind-set for having such discussions. Go to
school, do some real hard work, and come back in 10 years of so.
Dirk Vdm

You mean to say I should learn by rote, school physics as well as
advanced physics, the way you did?

You are here with the argument that airplanes cannot possibly fly
because they are heavier than air. Imbecile.
Dirk Vdm

This is just to remind you. You said, you don’t love physics. You just
find it interesting. Your anger says something else. I think you are
in love of physics, especially SR.

Ping alen...
My apologies, you were correct, there is no hope for Tamhane
either :-)
Dirk Vdm- Hide quoted text -
- Show quoted text -

I posted a message,
"Thanks for the compliments."
Why the message disappeared?

[Vilas Tamhane]

Post by Vilas Tamhane
I posted a message,
"Thanks for the compliments."
Why the message disappeared?

First tell me why any of your messages appear.

Of course for you to read it as you have read it.