Odd derivation of the GR gravitational shift formula

[m***@wanadoo.fr]

Odd derivation of the GR gravitational shift formula
The derivation is ultimately an odd mixture
of special relativity with a Newtonian formula!

[snip]

xxein1: Correct. But it is a velocity, not a speed - despite Wiki.
Imagine shooting off a projectile tangent to the horizon. It would
spend more time in a greater gravitation before it could escape. That
is why the velocity is perpendicular.

[snip remainder of imbecilic comments]

I think we are just floating in a sea of uncertainty with the gall to
claim a position within it.

Thank you for your comments.

Don't.
They suck big time.
As do yours.
Dirk Vdm

So, you are implying that the relativistic kinetic energy formula
K = mc^2(1/(1-sqrt(v^2/c^2)) - 1) should not be used in
the derivation of the shift.
You are not afraid of contradictions.

Marcel Luttgens

[m***@wanadoo.fr]

Odd derivation of the GR gravitational shift formula
The derivation is ultimately an odd mixture
of special relativity with a Newtonian formula!

[snip]

xxein1: Correct. But it is a velocity, not a speed - despite Wiki.
Imagine shooting off a projectile tangent to the horizon. It would
spend more time in a greater gravitation before it could escape. That
is why the velocity is perpendicular.

[snip remainder of imbecilic comments]

I think we are just floating in a sea of uncertainty with the gall to
claim a position within it.

Thank you for your comments.

Don't.
They suck big time.
As do yours.
Dirk Vdm

So, you are implying that the relativistic kinetic energy formula
K = mc^2(1/(1-sqrt(v^2/c^2)) - 1) should not be used in
the derivation of the shift.
You are not afraid of contradictions.

Marcel Luttgens

[m***@wanadoo.fr]

Odd derivation of the GR gravitational shift formula
The derivation is ultimately an odd mixture
of special relativity with a Newtonian formula!

[snip]

xxein1: Correct. But it is a velocity, not a speed - despite Wiki.
Imagine shooting off a projectile tangent to the horizon. It would
spend more time in a greater gravitation before it could escape. That
is why the velocity is perpendicular.

[snip remainder of imbecilic comments]

I think we are just floating in a sea of uncertainty with the gall to
claim a position within it.

Thank you for your comments.

Don't.
They suck big time.
As do yours.
Dirk Vdm

So, you are implying that the relativistic kinetic energy formula
K = mc^2(1/(1-sqrt(v^2/c^2)) - 1) should not be used in
the derivation of the shift.
You are not afraid of contradictions.

Marcel Luttgens

[m***@wanadoo.fr]

Post by m***@wanadoo.fr

Odd derivation of the GR gravitational shift formula
The derivation is ultimately an odd mixture
of special relativity with a Newtonian formula!

[snip]

xxein1: Correct. But it is a velocity, not a speed - despite Wiki.
Imagine shooting off a projectile tangent to the horizon. It would
spend more time in a greater gravitation before it could escape. That
is why the velocity is perpendicular.

[snip remainder of imbecilic comments]

I think we are just floating in a sea of uncertainty with the gall to
claim a position within it.

Thank you for your comments.

Don't.
They suck big time.
As do yours.
Dirk Vdm

So, you are implying that the relativistic kinetic energy formula
K = mc^2(1/(1-sqrt(v^2/c^2)) - 1) should not be used in
the derivation of the shift.
You are not afraid of contradictions.
Marcel Luttgens