For our Resident Troll - How to Critique

[PeterN]

With the next S-I results about to be posted, a word on critiquing the
photos submitted. "They're all crap" is not a critique.

Oh, so the truth is not part of a critique anymore. Of course.
Let me see: only comments from the annointed ones are allowed and they
have to be positive otherwise they are trolls. Right?

So, good luck with your submission. I'm sure the rest of the readers
of the newsgroup will be as kind to you as you have been to them in
the past.

Oh boy!...
LOL!

A critique certainly should be truthful. Indeed, I do not want anybody
saying my image is great, if indeed it is a POS. I tend to do a lot of
experimental work, though the images I submitted this month are pretty
much straight shots. Having said that I would hope that comments on my
images would be helpful, which we all know <> "kind." My main interest
is to improve my work. So, Noonsie, please be truthful. If you don't
like my image, give me the courtesy of saying why. And most importantly,
what you would have done to improve my image.

BTW I don't like to speak for others, but I suspect Tony Cooper feels
the same as I, on this subject.

[Charles E Hardwidge]

As usual your lowlife trolling fails to demonstrate anything when you
reply well after I did and well after you have read my reply while
claiming you don't.
Can't you understand your MO is now in the open, you stinky, coward
troll?

Content is king. Just killfile the bitch and move on.

[John McWilliams]

Of course he did, and no doubt he'll deny it, and end with a tirade of
clumsy insults.

As usual your lowlife trolling fails to demonstrate anything when you
reply well after I did and well after you have read my reply while
claiming you don't.

Er, show me the claim!

Can't you understand your MO is now in the open, you stinky, coward
troll?

Q.E.D.