Discussion:
Higgs Boson and Higgs Field
(too old to reply)
Mike
2009-07-04 21:55:04 UTC
Permalink
[...]
As expected you neither understood nor wished to learn. Thanks for
proving that you've learned nothing in 3 years.
Avoiding to answe again by appealing to someone else's ignorance?
Listen crank, people who go to prestigious universities are required
to take logic in first semester. Logic, is the foundation of
everything. In logic you learn formal and informal fallacies. Appeal
to ignorance, yours or someone else's, is an informal fallacy.

To the point now: prove how you get from F = dp/dt and p = hf / c to
F = IA / c.

I know, I know, wikipedia and Woolfram do not have a proof. The other
proofs use math you do not understand. Dirk went to dinner and he did
not reply to your email.

You are hopeless crank.
Eric Gisse
2009-07-04 23:32:10 UTC
Permalink
[...]
As expected you neither understood nor wished to learn. Thanks for
proving that you've learned nothing in 3 years.
Avoiding to answe again  by appealing to someone else's ignorance?
Listen crank, people who go to prestigious universities are required
to take logic in first semester.
That reminds me, Mike. You like to comment about my education - but
where did you get yours? Do you even have an education?
Logic, is the foundation of
everything. In logic you learn formal and informal fallacies. Appeal
to ignorance, yours or someone else's, is an informal fallacy.
So when you do the same thing, is it ok for me to call you out on it?
Promise not to get mad and shriek like a hyena?
To the point now: prove how you get from F = dp/dt and p = hf / c  to
F = IA / c.
I'm sorry I treated you like you were educated - it won't happen
again. I'll explain slowly this time.

Photons - notice how I'm being specific - carry a momentum hf / c. A
photon that is absorbed by a mirror imparts that hf/c to the mirror by
basic conservation of momentum. The time rate of change of the
momentum by the mirror is the force the mirror feels.

Nowhere did I claim you can step the linear momentum of the photon to
the force the mirror feels. That is a different and slightly more
difficult computation that I can't do from memory, so I gave you the
classical computation. I purposefully left out a little bit of
information to see if you could do it, and clearly you can't.

If you go back and use basic reading comprehension you'll see what I
mean. Go try.
I know, I know, wikipedia and Woolfram do not have a proof. The other
proofs use math you do not understand. Dirk went to dinner and he did
not reply to your email.
Why don't you try to make a fool out of me and complete the next step
of the proof I wrote down for you? The final answer is only like 5
lines away. Surely an armchair physicist like yourself should be able
to do such a trivial thing.
You are hopeless crank.
Yet you keep replying. Are you an attention whore or just that stupid?
Loading...